10 Best Movers Near Caledonia, NY

Unbiased Rankings Updated Monthly

Want help with the heavy lifting?

Get a quote now.

When every moving company in Caledonia, NY claims they're the best, how do you really know? We analyzed 49 moving companies in Caledonia across 57,554 review data points and more than 20,000 movers nationwide using our 11-point rating system to help you determine the best moving company in Caledonia. See the top 10 Caledonia movers below (our top recommendation is: Excellent Movers), get data-based information on Caledonia moving costs (expect to pay somewhere between $1,177 and $1,883), or filter movers to display the cheapest movers in Caledonia, or the top recommendation for a Caledonia long distance move out of New York.

Best Caledonia, NY Movers Featured Image

Best Moving Companies in Caledonia, NY

How Much Do Movers Cost in Caledonia, NY?

The average moving cost in Caledonia, NY is $1,263, which is based on an analysis from 126 customer reports across 9 different moving companies. In general, expect to pay somewhere between $1,177 and $1,883 for a typical move.

CompanyMedian Reported Moving CostAvg Move Duration
Sheridan Brothers Moving$6073 hours
Becker Movers$7933 hours
Joe's Moving Company$1,1773 hours
Pryority Movers Buffalo$1,1831 hours
Piece of Cake Moving & Storage$1,2633 hours
Tri-State Area Movers$1,7324.25 hours
Roadway Moving$1,8833.5 hours
Wayfinder Moving Services $4,4973.5 hours
Maffucci Moving & Storage$7,6279.5 hours
*Please be aware that the listed prices derive from historical customer feedback spanning several years and might not mirror the exact current rates of a company. Additionally, the anticipated cost range provided represents the 25th to 75th percentiles from the comprehensive reports of all Caledonia-based companies in our dataset.
Tipping Movers in Caledonia, NY icon

Tipping Movers in Caledonia, NY

Tipping your movers in Caledonia is a thoughtful way to show appreciation for their hard work, especially if they’re navigating local routes like Route 36 on a tight schedule. Most folks lean toward 10–20% of the total moving cost, or about $5 per mover per hour. This helps acknowledge the extra effort it takes to lug heavy items through the hilly roads around Livingston County. A final touch might be offering a refreshment, such as an ice-cold bottle of water or a cup of fresh apple cider from a local orchard to keep them hydrated and happy along the way.

Detailed 11-Point Review Analysis

We've analyzed more than 57,554 review data points to compare the top Caledonia movers across 11 important moving criteria. Here's how they stack up:

Quality iconQuality
Punctuality iconPunctuality
Affordability iconAffordability
Communication iconCommunication
Stick to Prices iconStick to Prices
Speed iconSpeed
Friendliness iconFriendliness
Will Hire Again iconWill Hire Again
Professionalism iconProfessionalism
Conflict Handling iconConflict Handling
Precision & Care iconPrecision & Care
Excellent Movers Logo

Excellent Movers

Exceptional9.24
97
68
94
93
77
79
90
96
90
93
86
Piece of Cake Moving & Storage Logo

Piece of Cake Moving & Storage

Exceptional9.17
87
93
90
95
85
95
94
86
81
96
80
Roadway Moving Logo

Roadway Moving

Exceptional9.15
78
79
46
72
91
91
86
71
88
99
90
Busy Bee Movers, LLC Logo

Busy Bee Movers, LLC

Exceptional9.12
82
85
84
85
88
85
85
89
89
80
85
Clancy Relocation & Logistics Logo

Clancy Relocation & Logistics

Exceptional9.11
86
83
58
94
91
89
95
87
96
80
86
Waterman moving And Delivery Logo

Waterman moving And Delivery

Exceptional9.09
89
92
89
77
75
85
73
89
86
85
85
Wayfinder Moving Services  Logo

Wayfinder Moving Services

Exceptional9.05
83
76
70
70
88
80
93
87
94
82
87
Mabey's Moving and Storage, Inc. Logo

Mabey's Moving and Storage, Inc.

Exceptional9.04
86
91
68
92
57
93
97
84
90
86
87
Interior Moving Services, Inc. Logo

Interior Moving Services, Inc.

Superb8.97
87
73
76
91
58
78
91
82
87
85
91
Bauer & Son Moving (Bauer Moving, Inc) Logo

Bauer & Son Moving (Bauer Moving, Inc)

Superb8.96
79
81
54
82
54
73
81
75
85
--
78

Percentile Ranking

0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
100
*Note: the above data points reflect a moving company's percentile ranking compared to all moving companies in New York.

Caledonia Moving Companies Historical Ranking

DIY Moves in Caledonia, NY icon

DIY Moves in Caledonia, NY

Planning a DIY move in Caledonia might seem budget-friendly at first, but keep in mind the hidden costs of truck rentals, gas, tolls on I-390, and unexpected equipment fees. You’ll also be responsible for safely packing and unloading everything yourself, which can be time-consuming if you’re juggling work or family obligations. Before committing, consider scoping out local rental deals with a quick search: Find a moving truck near Caledonia to compare options and make sure you’re prepared for all the details that come with going it alone.

Rankings You Can Trust background image
Trust Rankings icon

Dependable Rankings You Can Count On!

Our rankings are data-driven — movers cannot purchase a spot on our list. Here's why you can have confidence in our recommendations:

  • No Paid Placements: Every company earns its spot through merit, not payment.
  • Extensive Analysis: Evaluated over 24,000 movers across the country for our rankings.

Compare The Top-Ranked Caledonia Movers

These are the top recommended movers based on our unbiased & regularly updated ranking algorithm (NOT paid promotions)

Excellent Movers Logo

Excellent Movers

Exceptional9.24/10
based on 762+ data points

Spring Valley, NY, 10977

About Excellent Movers

The professionals at Excellent Movers are here to make your move simple. They know that moving can be stressful, so they...

Services

Pros

  • Efficient packing and moving
  • Professional and trustworthy team
  • Highly responsive and excellent customer service
  • Competitive pricing

Cons

  • Arrived later than scheduled in some cases
  • Some instances of items being broken
  • Rare cases of not receiving callbacks
  • Limited instances of leaving job early and not being careful

Moving Licenses

License TypeNumberStatusLast Verified
USDOT1736902Not Authorized1/10/2025
Read Our Detailed Review
1
Piece of Cake Moving & Storage Logo

Piece of Cake Moving & Storage

Exceptional9.17/10
based on 32,665+ data points

287 Park Ave S

New York City, NY, 10010

About Piece of Cake Moving & Storage

Based in Brooklyn, Piece of Cake was incorporated in 2017 and aims to combine superior customer service with competitive pricing. In...

Services

  • 24/7/365 Moving
  • Local Residential Moving Services
  • Long Distance Moving Services
  • Office and Commercial Moves
  • Small Moves
  • Last Minute Moves
  • Full Packing
  • Platinum Packing
  • Plastic Bin Hire
  • Piano Moving

Pros

  • Professional and respectful crew
  • Excellent communication throughout the process
  • Friendly and courteous service
  • Competitive and fair pricing

Cons

  • Inexperienced crew or took long breaks in some cases
  • Some incidents of broken items
  • Occasional long move times, missing elevator reservations
  • Rare occasions of unprofessional behavior e.g., fighting in apartment

Moving Licenses

License TypeNumberStatusLast Verified
USDOT3066988Authorized For HHG1/9/2025
Read Our Detailed Review
2
Roadway Moving Logo

Roadway Moving

Exceptional9.15/10
based on 2,770+ data points

888 S Columbus Ave

Mt Vernon, NY, 10550

About Roadway Moving

Roadway Moving, headquartered in New York City, has been providing customizable moving services since 2008. As well-recognized movers serving Yonkers, NY,...

Services

  • Local Moving
  • Long Distance Moving
  • Commercial Moving
  • Moving and Storage Services
  • Packing Services
  • Art Movers
  • Piano Moving
  • Pool Table Moving
  • Residential Moving
  • White Gloves Moving

Pros

  • Extremely communicative and proactive
  • Professional and courteous teams
  • Efficient and quick moving process
  • Attention to detail in packing and moving

Cons

  • Rare cases of damaged goods
  • Issues with honoring claims and agreements in some instances
  • Some cases of poor customer response until public pressure applied
  • Occasional late arrivals and delivery delays

Moving Licenses

License TypeNumberStatusLast Verified
USDOT1854436Authorized For HHG1/11/2025
Read Our Detailed Review
3
Busy Bee Movers, LLC Logo

Busy Bee Movers, LLC

Exceptional9.12/10
based on 327+ data points

162 Albany Shaker Rd

Rotterdam, NY, 12306

About Busy Bee Movers, LLC

Busy Bee Movers, LLC lives up to its name with a strong work ethic and efficient timing. It's hard to find...

Services

  • Residential Moving services
  • Commercial Moving
  • Long Distance Moves
  • Packing services
  • Short notice moves
  • Light Commercial moving
  • Piano movers

Pros

  • Super respectful and professional.
  • Highly efficient, often completing moves quicker than expected.
  • Offers very reasonable and competitive pricing.
  • Excellent customer service, from responsiveness to care for belongings.

Cons

  • Quality has greatly diminished over the years.

Moving Licenses

License TypeNumberStatusLast Verified
USDOT2783375Not Authorized1/10/2025
Read Our Detailed Review
4
Clancy Relocation & Logistics Logo

Clancy Relocation & Logistics

Exceptional9.11/10
based on 853+ data points

2963 NY-22

Patterson, NY, 12563

About Clancy Relocation & Logistics

Moving is more than just packing stuff into boxes and shipping them off to another location; Clancy Relocation & Logistics aims...

Services

  • Residential Moving
  • Commercial Moving
  • Household Moving
  • Storage Services
  • Packing & Crating
  • International Moving
  • Office Moving
  • Furniture Installation
  • Rigging
  • Data Center Moving

Pros

  • Extremely careful with furniture
  • On time for appointments and moves
  • Fair and transparent pricing
  • Professional and courteous team

Cons

  • Belongings arrived damaged in some cases
  • Arrived late for a virtual estimate
  • Some cases of overpricing mentioned
  • Issues with items being held hostage for more money in rare instances
Read Our Detailed Review
5
Waterman moving And Delivery Logo

Waterman moving And Delivery

Exceptional9.09/10
based on 281+ data points

Rochester, NY, 14614

About Waterman moving And Delivery

Waterman Moving And Delivery is a professional moving company with over four years of experience, providing quality and affordable services. Based...

Services

  • Cheap moving services
  • Local moving services
  • Small residential moves and deliveries
  • Hourly moving rates
  • Packing services
  • Storage services
  • Residential moves and deliveries
  • Affordable moves
  • Stress-free moves
  • Experienced professional movers

Pros

  • Always on time or early.
  • Offers very reasonable quotes.
  • Highly professional and polite team.
  • Exceptional care with belongings and furniture.

Cons

    Read Our Detailed Review
    6
    Wayfinder Moving Services  Logo

    Wayfinder Moving Services

    Exceptional9.05/10
    based on 1,098+ data points

    75 Comet Ave

    Buffalo, NY, 14216

    About Wayfinder Moving Services

    Established in 2018, Wayfinder Moving Services has locations in both Buffalo, NY and Jamestown. As a business that specializes in...

    Services

    • Cheap moving services
    • Local moving services
    • Long-distance moving services
    • Cross-country moving services
    • International moving services
    • Small moving services
    • Piano moving services
    • Pool table moving services
    • Appliance moving services
    • Commercial moving services

    Pros

    • Exceptionally professional team.
    • Consistently careful with belongings.
    • Efficient and quick moving process.
    • Very responsive and helpful customer service.

    Cons

    • Relatively rare instances of arriving late.
    • Occasional issues with subcontractors leading to disappointment.
    • Some cases of communication delays.
    • Infrequent, but reported damage to items.

    Moving Licenses

    License TypeNumberStatusLast Verified
    USDOT3104397Authorized For HHG1/9/2025
    Read Our Detailed Review
    7
    Mabey's Moving and Storage, Inc. Logo

    Mabey's Moving and Storage, Inc.

    Exceptional9.04/10
    based on 1,202+ data points

    515 3rd Avenue Extension

    Rensselaer, NY, 12144

    About Mabey's Moving and Storage, Inc.

    Mabey's Moving and Storage, Inc. is a massive one-stop solution for everything you'll ever need in moving and storage. It offers...

    Services

    • Residential Moving
    • Commercial Moving
    • International Moving
    • Self Storage
    • Mobile Storage
    • Records Management
    • Warehousing
    • Truck Service
    • Packing

    Pros

    • Always live up to their word and their estimates.
    • Professional and respected instructions.
    • Highly communicative throughout the process.
    • Handled belongings carefully and with respect.

    Cons

    • Final payment was a bit higher than the quoted estimate.
    • Bill was $4000 over the estimate.
    • New Knotty pine walls scuffed and furniture damaged.
    • Forced to pay a higher price than quoted.

    Moving Licenses

    License TypeNumberStatusLast Verified
    USDOT1218087Not Authorized1/10/2025
    Read Our Detailed Review
    8
    Interior Moving Services, Inc. Logo

    Interior Moving Services, Inc.

    Superb
    claimed company icon
    8.97/10
    based on 970+ data points

    157 La Grange Ave

    Rochester, NY, 14613

    About Interior Moving Services, Inc.

    Located in Rochester, New York, Interior Moving Services has close to three decades of moving expertise, serving both residential and commercial...

    Services

    • Local residential moving
    • Local commercial moving
    • Long-distance residential moving
    • Long-distance commercial moving
    • Secure containerized storage
    • Equipment rental for commercial enterprises
    • Packing supplies included in initial quote
    • Climate-controlled storage vaults
    • Onsite packing services
    • Onsite packing estimate

    Pros

    • Provides seamless communication from start to finish.
    • Efficient, careful, and speedy service.
    • Professionals in handling items, including reassembling.
    • Competitive pricing with no hidden fees.

    Cons

    • Scams reported related to adding extra hours.
    • Slow start affecting overall paid time.
    • Instances of furniture not being wrapped resulting in damage.
    • Some cases of lateness with insufficient notification.

    Moving Licenses

    License TypeNumberStatusLast Verified
    USDOT1498819Authorized For HHG1/10/2025
    Read Our Detailed Review
    9
    Bauer & Son Moving (Bauer Moving, Inc) Logo

    Bauer & Son Moving (Bauer Moving, Inc)

    Superb8.96/10
    based on 353+ data points

    434 Elmgrove Rd

    Rochester, NY, 14606

    About Bauer & Son Moving (Bauer Moving, Inc)

    Bauer & Son Moving has been serving clients as a local, family-owned company since 1960 in the Rochester, NY area. They...

    Services

    • Local Moving
    • Senior Relocation
    • Apartment Moving
    • General Moving
    • Piano Moving

    Pros

    • Very professional and respectful
    • Pricing is more than fair
    • Consistently on-time or early
    • Effective and steady communication

    Cons

    • Some cases of unprofessional handling
    • Hidden charge items leading to customer surprise
    • Rare complaints about longer than expected moves
    • Infrequent slow customer service responses

    Moving Licenses

    License TypeNumberStatusLast Verified
    USDOT348429Not Authorized1/10/2025
    Read Our Detailed Review
    10
    Loading map...
    How we review icon

    How do we review a moving company?

    Imagine the challenge of sifting through and reading every single review a moving company has ever received. Could you spot the fake reviews? Could you formulate a well-rounded analyses, or would you be left relying on a gut feeling?

    Our rigorous evaluation process addresses this by meticulously vetting each moving company based on 11 crucial aspects of the moving experience:

    • 1. Quality

      Overall quality of the service provided on moving day.

    • 2. Punctuality

      Did the crew show up on-time with the required equipment?

    • 3. Affordability

      1 = extremely expensive, 10 = extremely affordable

    • 4. Communication

      Was the office staff quick to respond to questions prior to moving day? Did the moving crew notify you on the day of move regarding any changes to the original schedule? If there were any issues to resolve after moving day, was an office manager quick to respond and address problems encountered?

    • 5. Stick to Prices

      Was a lowball quote provided to earn business only to see the final moving day price increase substantially?

    • 6. Speed

      Did the movers seem to take their precious time in an attempt to increase the overall cost of the move? Remember, moving is HARD work and some breaks should be expected!

    • 7. Friendliness

      Was the moving crew cordial and friendly to be around on moving day?

    • 8. Will Hire Again

      How likely a customer is to hire the same movers again for their next move.

    • 9. Professionalism

      Did the moving crew behave in a professional manner on moving day?

    • 10. Conflict Handling

      Accidents can and will likely happen at some point on moving day. How a moving company responds to these accidents can say a lot about the company.

    • 11. Precision & Care

      Were walls scratched? Did furniture get scuffed, broken, or lost?

    Labor-Only Moves in Caledonia, NY icon

    Labor-Only Moves in Caledonia, NY

    Sometimes, you only need extra hands to load or unload your belongings in Caledonia without renting a full-service moving truck. This is where labor-only services come in. You can connect with hourly movers in Caledonia who specialize in simply providing the muscle power. They’re perfect when tackling a smaller apartment move on Route 5 or when you already have your own transportation lined up but need help with the heavy lifting.

    List of All Caledonia Moving Companies Analyzed

    See all of our Caledonia moving company reviews
    • Piece of Cake Moving & Storage
    • Pryority Movers Buffalo
    • Wayfinder Moving Services
    • Diamond Moving & Storage
    • Corrigan Moving Systems
    • M & J Movers Inc
    • Interior Moving Services, Inc.
    • Sheridan Brothers Moving
    • Becker Movers
    • Joe's Moving Company
    • Clark Moving & Storage
    • Corrigan Moving Systems
    • Bauer & Son Moving (Bauer Moving, Inc)
    • Always Moving
    • Caccamise Moving
    • Champion Moving & Storage
    • Mabey's Moving and Storage, Inc.
    • Don's Moving & Storage Inc
    • Arnoff Moving & Storage
    • Busy Bee Movers, LLC
    • Clark Moving & Storage Of Albany
    • Clancy Relocation & Logistics
    • New York to Florida Movers
    • Millennial Moving Solutions
    • Tri-State Area Movers
    • Excellent Movers
    • Reliable Movers
    • Dan's Moving & Storage Inc
    • Adirondack Moving Company, LLC
    • Maffucci Moving & Storage
    • Highline Moving and Delivery
    • Tyler’s Moving
    • PODS Moving & Storage
    • Ken's Neat Moving & Storage
    • Bold Moving & Storage
    • Waterman moving And Delivery
    • Rochester Moving & Storage
    • E-Z Movers Inc
    • McAvey Moving Company Inc
    • Kimiya Services Inc
    • U-Pack
    • Two Men and a Truck
    • Roadway Moving
    • Morgan Manhattan Moving and Storage
    • Lake Country Moving & Storage
    • Abbey Trucking : Moving and Storage
    • Murphys Will Move You
    • Upstate Movers
    • First Class Moving & Removal LLC
    Specialty Moves in Caledonia, NY icon

    Specialty Moves in Caledonia, NY

    Whether it’s an antique piano you inherited from a family member in nearby Rochester or a beloved pool table you’ve enjoyed for years, specialty moves require a trained hand. Trust local piano movers for delicate instruments, and count on pool table movers who’ve handled tricky corners around Caledonia’s historic district. They’ll have the right tools to protect your valuables, whether it’s a fragile statue or a heavy gun safe, ensuring each item arrives in perfect condition.

    CTA background image

    Hire better movers!

    Make an easier move.
    Best Caledonia, NY Movers Featured Image